The short answer
Choose a garden room if you want a separate space for work, exercise or hobbies, on a tighter budget, with little disruption and no planning application in most cases.
Choose an extension if you need more space inside the house itself, such as a bigger kitchen, an extra bedroom or a downstairs bathroom, and you have the budget and patience for a bigger project.
Side by side comparison
| Garden room | Single storey extension | |
|---|---|---|
| Typical cost per m² | £1,400 to £2,500 | £2,500 to £4,000+ |
| Typical total for about 15 m² | £22,000 to £38,000 | £40,000 to £70,000+ |
| Planning permission | Usually not needed in England under permitted development | Often permitted development, but larger designs need permission |
| Building regulations | Usually exempt under 15 m² without sleeping | Always needed |
| Time on site | 3 to 10 days | 3 to 6 months |
| Disruption to the house | Very little | Significant, often including the kitchen |
| Professional fees | Usually none | Architect, structural engineer, building control |
| Use for sleeping | Usually needs planning permission | Yes |
| Effect on value | Adds appeal and some value | Usually adds more value |
| Can be moved or removed | Often | No |
These are typical UK ranges and include VAT. Only written quotes give firm prices.
Cost per square metre
The biggest difference is cost. A garden room is built off site or from a kit, on a light base, with no need to break into the house. An extension needs deep foundations, a steel or two, a new roof tied into the house, and usually a full rebuild of whatever room it joins.
A typical insulated garden room costs about £1,400 to £2,500 per square metre fitted, including the base, installation and basic electrics. A single storey extension typically costs £2,500 to £4,000 or more per square metre once you add design fees, building control, finishes and VAT. In London and the South East, extension costs often sit at the top of that range.
For the same budget, you often get roughly twice the floor space with a garden room. See our garden room cost guide for detailed prices by size.
Planning
Most garden rooms in England are built under permitted development, which means no planning application, as long as they meet limits on height, position and coverage. The most important one is a maximum height of 2.5 metres within 2 metres of a boundary.
Single storey rear extensions can also be permitted development, but the limits are tighter and depend on the type of house. Larger extensions, two storey extensions and many side extensions need full planning permission, which typically takes about 8 weeks once the application is valid.
Read our planning permission guide for the full garden room rules. Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland have different rules, so check with your council.
Building regulations
A garden room under 15 square metres with no sleeping accommodation is usually exempt from building regulations. Rooms between 15 and 30 square metres are usually exempt if there is no sleeping accommodation and they are at least 1 metre from a boundary or built mostly of non combustible materials. Electrical work must still meet Part P.
An extension always needs building regulations approval. That means drawings, structural calculations, inspections and a completion certificate, all of which add cost and time.
Disruption
A garden room is installed at the bottom of the garden. Apart from a trench for the cable, the house is untouched and you can carry on as normal.
An extension usually means months of builders, dust and noise. If the extension joins the kitchen, you may be without one for weeks. Many families find this the hardest part of the project.
Timescales
| Stage | Garden room | Extension |
|---|---|---|
| Design and quotes | 2 to 4 weeks | 1 to 3 months |
| Approvals | Usually none | 2 to 3 months |
| Lead time | 4 to 12 weeks | Builders often booked months ahead |
| Build | 3 to 10 days | 3 to 6 months |
Value
An extension adds floor space to the house itself. Valuers and buyers count it as part of the home, so a good extension usually adds more value than it costs in many parts of the country.
A garden room is valued differently. It adds appeal, particularly to buyers who work from home, but it is not counted as part of the house. A well built, insulated room with power and broadband is a strong selling point. A cheap, damp building can put buyers off.
If adding value is your main goal, an extension usually wins. If you want useful space at the lowest cost per square metre, a garden room usually wins.
Which is right for you?
Ask yourself these questions:
- Do you need the space inside the house? A bigger kitchen or an extra bedroom points to an extension.
- Do you want separation? Work, music, exercise and hobbies often work better away from the house.
- What is your budget? If you have £20,000 to £40,000, a garden room gives you far more space for the money.
- How long can you wait? A garden room can be in use within weeks of ordering.
- How long will you stay? If you plan to move soon, a cheaper garden room may be the smarter spend.
Put your own size into the garden room cost calculator to see a typical price, then get quotes to compare.